This may seem like a question with an obvious yes. People will always need to eat. The question, however, is much deeper and more nuanced than that.
For the last 20 years, the narrative shifted from an era of cheap grains, struggling farmers, and a world that was uninterested in agriculture, to a story of growing population, biofuels, limited land area growth, and climate change. We shifted from a world of abundance to questions about shortages, exploding land values, and glowing optimism in agriculture. But can that last?
Between demographic shifts, technological advancements, genetic gains, and changing priorities, the future doesn’t look as bright as many may think for production agriculture. Let’s have a look at the coming challenges—and whether the future for us in the business of farming is truly as bright as we’ve been led to believe. Then, we will look past them, to see if these are cyclical challenges, or genuine threats to our future.
Our Oldest Occupation
Our best archeological records put the beginning of agriculture about 10,000 years ago in the Fertile Crescent in Mesopotamia, modern-day Iraq, Iran, Turkey, Israel, and Syria. It likely got its true beginning some time before that, with some records of farming going several thousand years ahead of this. It also started in many places simultaneously, in China, Mesoamerica, Africa, and others.
The crops I grow on my farm hail from the Fertile Crescent, including lentils, wheat, and flax.
For most of agriculture’s history, farmers were peasants, living below what we now define as extreme poverty. There was no crop insurance, no credit, no land ownership for almost all of them, and no way to survive multiple crop failures. This really didn’t change until the early 20th century, and even then, farming was still a difficult business to make a good living in.
That’s why there’s so few of us left. Most people moved on to other things (read more about that here).
While there were some great periods in farming, including the 1970’s, it’s never been a business that’s been for the faint of heart. Here in Western Canada, aside from the aforementioned 70’s, it’s really only been the last 20 years that we’ve seen true, sustained profitability in the cropping sector. And of course, that comes and goes year to year, depending on weather and commodity prices. It’s also worth noting that while the cropping sector has seen profitability, its return on assets is quite poor compared with other industries.
I mention all this to point out that we may be living in a true anomaly: a rare period where farmers can actually be consistently profitable, leading to an historic rise in land values.
Naturally, this raises the question: why? What’s different this time?
Why—and How—Has Agriculture Been Profitable?
In the early 2000’s, farmers were in trouble. The 90’s weren’t exactly great times to be farming. It was difficult enough that my parents sent a letter to the government back in 1999, and even went to rallies advocating for better income stabilization programs for farmers. The 1980’s bankrupted many farmers, the 90’s kept incomes tight for the survivors, and the early 2000’s put the final nail in the coffin for many. Decades of weak commodity prices put the industry in a state of despair that’s hard to grasp today.
If you make something cheap enough, however, for long enough, eventually you’ll find a new use for it. And that’s exactly what happened. The Renewable Fuel Standard got its start in 2005 in the US, requiring 4 billion gallons of renewable fuel. With oil prices rising and grains still cheap, the timing was perfect (read more here).
By 2008, 3.7 billion bushels of corn was being used for ethanol, a fifth of the entire US crop. As corn rose, it pulled the other crops along with it, with prices peaking (on US futures markets) at $7.99 for corn, $16.37 for soybeans, and $13 for wheat, while oil found $147 per barrel. While the peaks broke down fast and the markets collapsed during the Financial Crisis and Great Recession, this was a structural change—the old highs in those markets became the new lows, and an era of generally good times for grain prices carried on.
Of course, biofuels weren’t the only driver. China was becoming a major industrial economy, with a rapidly growing middle class, and it was substantially increasing its imports. Other developing economies did likewise. There was no end to the optimism for farmers. I heard it everywhere while I was in university—we would need more food in the next forty years than all of the last 10,000.
To their credit, this turned out to be true. Demand continued (and continues) to grow and if land values are any clue, farmers have done well in this period (area dependent of course), even if that’s been slipping lately.
But can it last?
Demographic Collapse
For the last several hundred years, the human population has seen nothing but increases in its population. The last time our population actually declined was during the Black Plague in the mid-14th century. Yes, that was 700 years ago, when our population peaked at about 450 million. For the first time in human history, we are headed for a population decline not caused by calamity—but by choice.
Few recognize the severity of what’s happening—and what’s coming. Some countries aren’t just below replacement level, but headed for real population collapse. South Korea, for example, has a birth rate of just 0.7, far below the replacement rate of 2.1. This will change their entire civilization, just not right away. In 2050, it won’t look much different, with about a 10% decrease in population. But by 2075, their population will be cut in half. In a century, their population could collapse by 85%. The collapse is exponential as it feeds on itself.
South Korea might be the most extreme case today, but it’s far from alone: China, Germany, Italy, Japan, are all headed for the same wall, just slower.
While this creates real questions about demand for our products, there is an entire other question to consider: our population will be older. Much older. Fewer and fewer working age people will be supporting more and more retirees. This will be an unprecedented challenge. One that geopolitical analysts like Peter Zeihan claim will result in unprecedented civilizational change—or even collapse.
That, however, is a discussion for another day (read more here).
It is worth noting here, though, that the collapsing population of young people, particularly in developed economies, will raise serious problems with simply getting the work done. Who will do it all?
Will Technology Make Farmers Obsolete?
Just a few years ago, there was a lot of angst in the animal agriculture world: if you can produce lab-grown meat with ten times less land, who will buy real animals? And of course there was the whole plant protein fad as well.
We know how both of those turned out: most of the money invested into that space has been lost. But that doesn’t mean it will never happen.
It isn’t just lab produced meat. At least 30% of the food produced gets wasted. What if we solved that problem? What if we cross some biological hurdle to double yields of staples like wheat or rice? In a world of constant disruption, it feels like anything could happen tomorrow.
In fact, it’s theoretically possible to produce food directly from the air. Solar Foods, from Finland, has apparently been doing just that, producing a variety of food products from atmospheric CO2 through a process called hydrogen-oxidizing gas fermentation. They aren’t the only ones, either, as there are a number of companies trying to make a go of this.
The Danger of Relying on Policy
One of the real consequences of the biofuel mandates is that they are policy. The stroke of a pen can change them overnight. All the mandates we rely on for demand, whether in corn, soybeans, or canola, depend on governments maintaining them. They also assume we will continue to need fuel at all; this could change, if electric vehicles ever hit the mainstream.
Priorities can change. We’ve seen that very recently: the policies put in place for biofuels were initially intended to reduce the US’s reliance on foreign oil. Now that the US is itself an energy exporter, could that change the math? If the US changes their policy, would Canada and other countries follow suit? Also, much of the push for biofuels was in the name of fighting climate change. That is no longer a priority for many governments, including our own here in Canada.
Will Climate Change Make Farming Impossible?
We’ve been told climate change will increase weather extremes, leading to more droughts, more intense droughts, and more severe weather swings. We’ve even been told that southern Saskatchewan could end up with a climate more similar to Texas today. Based on some of the models, we could see a temperature increase of 3-5 degrees Celsius by the end of this century.
If this were to verify, it could make the 1930’s look like normal. While that doesn’t make farming itself untenable, it does change the distribution of it, and could create significant challenges in different areas.
Let’s Take a Closer Look at the Threats
Climate modelling is just that: modelling. Every forecast of a warmer climate has overstated what’s actually happened. While there is a lot of debate over climate change that we don’t need to get into here, suffice to say that the consequences are mixed and there are no guarantees of good or bad effects in Western Canada (or in most places).
No, climate change won’t make farming impossible. Not here, not anywhere. In fact, there’s been a lot of benefit to all the emissions we’ve pumped into the atmosphere. Since the 1980’s, the globe has greened so much that we’ve essentially added a land mass the size of the continental United States. There’s been other benefits, too: our growing season here in Western Canada has gotten longer, with a little more growing degree days, too. This is not a one-sided, everything will get worse scenario.
Demographics are not destiny. Fertility is reversible—for example, France has managed to hold onto a fertility rate of 1.8-1.9 for decades through strong pro-family policies. Note, that’s not hitting replacement rate of 2.1, but it’s close enough that it will take a long time for population to meaningfully decline. Other countries, like Canada, have overcome low fertility rates with immigration, although that certainly comes with its own consequences and the very high rates of the past several years is simply not sustainable.
Regardless, reversing population decline, while not impossible, is highly unlikely. Unfortunately, we are likely too far into this trend to turn it around, and we will have to work through the consequences. This is, however, a slow-moving train, and we will be unlikely to truly notice it as demand destruction for several decades. Indeed, this won’t be a problem for my generation of farmers, and may not even be one for my kids’ generation.
Peak population does not equal peak demand. As populations get richer, they consume more protein, which requires more calories of production. That’s part of the reason we will see demand grow long after population peaks. Yes, eventually, we will see the other side of this demand curve. But that’s many decades into the future, and so much can happen by then that worrying about demand that far out is just futile.
That, too, is just one part of demand for agricultural goods. Biofuels and other bio-products have tremendous opportunities. Even if we electrify the passenger vehicle fleet around the world, industrial diesel demand will not go away. Electrifying mining equipment, or construction machinery, or farm equipment, may never be logical. Certainly, electrifying jets doesn’t sound appealing at all.
Electricity demand is skyrocketing right now because of data center construction for artificial intelligence. Say what you want about the accuracy of your AI model, this is a trend with some legs, and keeping up with this demand is going to require all the power we can generate. This means biofuels will continue to be a major source of demand for the foreseeable future—not for the data centers themselves, but for all the fossil fuel generated power we will need to build and maintain them.
So yes, policy change could damage biofuel demand, but that does not look like a reasonable worry for the foreseeable future. And as mentioned previously— there are a lot of opportunities to use our production in ways no one has thought of yet.
What about the threat of technology? Anything could happen here tomorrow. Perhaps lab grown meat will take off once we get cheap, abundant power. While this “food” may interest some people, the vast majority will demand real food. This may create a different demand stream: nutritionally dense food. We aren’t currently incentivized to produce nutritionally dense food, but maybe someday that will change.
“Growing” calories from the air or in a lab may be theoretically possible, but the economics are horrific, and may never compete with field-grown crops. These processes require energy, lots of it, so you need massive quantities of cheap, reliable electricity. That is a major constraint with data centers soaking up any electricity they can get their hands on. We are a long, long way from power being so cheap and abundant that we can synthesize food cheaper than we can grow it.
As for other threats, like how demographic collapse could cause labour shortages, or even war, there’s little use worrying about these threats. They may or may not happen and they may be good or bad for agriculture.
The Path Ahead
We have seen outstanding advancements in yields through some of humanity’s greatest achievements: synthetic nitrogen fertilizer production, herbicides, genetically modified crops, hybridization, gene editing, and so much more. We not only kept pace with human population growth, we blew past it. We have made food so marvellously cheap that we burn it for fuel. Every time we’ve found another amazing advancement in crop yields, every time we produce more and lower the price, we find another use for it. Cheap grains have a way of finding new uses, new demand.
Yes, the world is changing, and we are no longer in a world where we can rely on a growing population to increase demand. However, I think I’ve laid out enough arguments and evidence that this won’t end prosperity in agriculture. Perhaps it will change; perhaps the era of maximizing production will someday be left behind. The era that replaces it may use less fertilizer, more perennials, and a simpler and cheaper production system.
I trust one thing more than anything else: the ingenuity of farmers. We are one of the world’s oldest occupations. No matter what the world throws at us, from difficult weather, to challenges with demand, to supply chain disruptions, we will weather the storm. Despite all the disruption this industry has faced over the last century of change, farmers are, generally speaking, in better shape than they ever have been.
There’s no industry that offers a better future than this one. This farmer, with eyes wide open to the threats ahead, is optimistic about agriculture’s future.